Are stores like Walmart required to post this sign?

[Blackjack]

Wouldn’t any store that sells any type of firearm have to post a sign that guns are welcome due to the fact that you have to take possession on the property? By default every store that sells must allow any firearm. There is no way around it this is the sign provided by NYS.

 

[4WHLDRFTN]

Rod & Gun clubs have to post that sign

 

[NY Chamorro]

This is so dumb, it’s like having to put a sign on a restaurant, that says “you can eat here”

 

[Celt]

This is so dumb, it’s like having to put a sign on a restaurant, that says “you can eat here”

And if they dont, and you are caught then its a fel0ny.

There is no way this stands. What recourse does the SCOTUS have for states that blatantly violate/circumvent their ruling?

 

[Blackjack]

The point here is if they sell they MUST allow.

There is no way around it to take possession lawfully. The sign must be displayed.

 

[Steal2B]

The point here is if they sell they MUST allow.

There is no way around it to take possession lawfully. The sign must be displayed.

Maybe Walmarts and big mall chainstores that want to sell guns and not post the signs may still sell if they transfer to a mom and pop ffls. They may also need to hire exempt LEO types to handle the product as well as the shipper handling the product. Yeah FUKH and her crew are arrogant dumb asses insulting all with this petulant temper tantrum legislation.

 

[Saltwater60]

I would say no because Walmart is well-known for saying they would prefer you not to open carry, but carrying in their stores is allowed. A few other stores have made this same claim as well. I would say that is expressed consent.

 

[Saltwater60]

The point here is if they sell they MUST allow.

There is no way around it to take possession lawfully. The sign must be displayed.

How about the Hamburg fair gun show this weekend? They strip you of your pistol at the door and zip tie it open through the chamber and give it back. They two don’t have to go hand in hand.

 

[Blackjack]

How about the Hamburg fair gun show this weekend? They strip you of your pistol at the door and zip tie it open through the chamber and give it back. They two don’t have to go hand in hand.

Walmart does not search and disarm and you still have your weapon at the gun show.

To take possession the sign must be in place. It’s the law. Even at the gun show.

 

[Cavalry]

I cannot remember if it was Walmart or Runnings or even both, but upon purchace they walk you to the door and hand you the gun outside.

 

[Russ Woody]

I bought 1 gun at Walmart and they had to walk me to the door with it. A fucking 22 LR. I told the guy when he handed me my gun "I've been carrying a handgun the whole time".

He laughed and said he didn't care.

 

[nortatoga]

Walmart already does..

 

[Blackjack]

Walmart already does..

View attachment 172615

That does not meet the requirements of NYS to lawfully take possession.

 

[nortatoga]

That does not meet the requirements of NYS to lawfully take possession.

The taking possession has to do with buying a semi-auto rifle. This thread is about...

"Are stores like Walmart required to post this sign?"​

for carrying while shopping.

 

[Deplorable Me]

This is so dumb, it’s like having to put a sign on a restaurant, that says “you can eat here”

Welcome to NY.

 

[Blackjack]

The taking possession has to do with buying a semi-auto rifle. This thread is about...

"Are stores like Walmart required to post this sign?"​

for carrying while shopping.

The sign is required by law for any possession of any firearm on property.
Right now you can be arrested for having a shotgun you just bought in the parking lot loading it into your car.

 

[Jmac00]

Wouldn’t any store that sells any type of firearm have to post a sign that guns are welcome due to the fact that you have to take possession on the property? By default every store that sells must allow any firearm. There is no way around it this is the sign provided by NYS.
View attachment 172607

who cares ???

 

[nortatoga]

The taking possession has to do with buying a semi-auto rifle. This thread is about...

The sign is required by law for any possession of any firearm on property.
Right now you can be arrested for having a shotgun you just bought in the parking lot loading it into your car.

WE may just be Doomed!!!

 

[Blackjack]

who cares ???

This is just one example of how stupid the law is. It’s literally a catch 22. Someone will be arrested and made an example of. It needs to be exposed to change it.

 

[nortatoga]

 

[tirwin1]

The point here is if they sell they MUST allow.

There is no way around it to take possession lawfully. The sign must be displayed.

No they don't. Just because you believe it doesn't mean the store (or the world) agrees with you.

Your point is logical but that doesn't mean anything in New York.

 

[Saltwater60]

Walmart does not search and disarm and you still have your weapon at the gun show.

To take possession the sign must be in place. It’s the law. Even at the gun show.

They don’t search and disarm you at the gun show either.
My point is if a sign is there saying guns are allowed, and yes I’d agree it has to be how can they ask you to disarm now? It’s either allowed or it’s not right? Also at the gun show I can buy a new pistol, magazines, and ammo to load said gun, but they zip tie the one I have at the door? I just walk right passed them and say nothing in the past.

 

[Saltwater60]

It’s a sign or consent. Them saying we would ask you to refrain from open carrying firearms in our store is consent to have a gun at their store.
I’m not putting a sign up at my house saying guns welcome, but if any of you ever come over you have my consent to carry there until you’re an asshole while on site. Not saying anyone here is being an asshole, but that’s my rules.

 

[Saltwater60]

I bought 1 gun at Walmart and they had to walk me to the door with it. A fucking 22 LR. I told the guy when he handed me my gun "I've been carrying a handgun the whole time".

He laughed and said he didn't care.

Still taking possession of the gun on their property. They own the vestibule and likely the parking lot.

 

[nortatoga]

It’s a sign or consent. Them saying we would ask you to refrain from open carrying firearms in our store is consent to have a gun at their store.
I’m not putting a sign up at my house saying guns welcome, but if any of you ever come over you have my consent to carry there until you’re an asshole while on site. Not saying anyone here is being an asshole, but that’s my rules.

Careful some here will say your violating thier rights !!!

 

[dwa12479]

Do any NY Walmarts still sell guns? I've only been into maybe 2 Walmarts in NY in the last 10 years, and neither sells guns.

 

[Truebeliever]

The way the law was written, if the employee selling the gun, takes possession of it at any point inside the store , they are guilty of a felony unless the store has one of those signs.

 

[ManualF150]

Do any NY Walmarts still sell guns? I've only been into maybe 2 Walmarts in NY in the last 10 years, and neither sells guns.

Yes, all mine do.

 

[thegatman]

Do any NY Walmarts still sell guns? I've only been into maybe 2 Walmarts in NY in the last 10 years, and neither sells guns.

Geneseo Walmart sells guns as well as Canadaigua.

 

[Saltwater60]

Do any NY Walmarts still sell guns? I've only been into maybe 2 Walmarts in NY in the last 10 years, and neither sells guns.

The one in north Tonawanda does. They have a few .22’s and some shotguns here and there.