IF you get in trouble. (Storing guns with FFL)

Brawny71

Brawny71

.357 mag
Messages
675
Reaction score
885
Location
Jefferson County
Just wanted to stimulate thought. Sometimes we get in trouble. Aggravated DUI, Red Flag accusation, domestic investigation, child neglect investigation; things which may be proven to be invalid or you found innocent. In this state, part of that means you should be concerned about your fire arms during the process. IF you get in trouble it may be a really good idea to turn your fire arms over to a local FFL for safe keeping. I do this in my area. Safe Storage allows them to be secured and safe. I recently coordinated to pick up a sizable collection from the NYSP. Although the guns were not part of the persons crime, they all had been taken up. ALL of them were also destroyed even though the family was in the process of recovering them (to include many of family value and sentiment). The latitude of what is NYS compliant is also very interesting with no case law to base it on or supporting findings. If you are living in the grey it is not designed for your protection.

I know there will be a lot of posts about 2d Amend being your permit and communist this and that. But IF you get in trouble, proaction and showing due diligence goes a long way and your local FFL isn’t going to destroy them or add them to their personal collection. An FFL has to put them on their register and account for them. They don’t destroy them unless law enforcement comes with an order and recovers them. Your local FFL can keep them while your innocence until prove guilty takes place.

Ok, let the lamenting begin…..
 
GOPerfect

GOPerfect

.950 JDJ
U.S. Military
Messages
32,445
Reaction score
74,736
Location
No longer Secret, thanks DR. Evil
Brawny71 said:
Just wanted to stimulate thought. Sometimes we get in trouble. Aggravated DUI, Red Flag accusation, domestic investigation, child neglect investigation; things which may be proven to be invalid or you found innocent. In this state, part of that means you should be concerned about your fire arms during the process. IF you get in trouble it may be a really good idea to turn your fire arms over to a local FFL for safe keeping. I do this in my area. Safe Storage allows them to be secured and safe. I recently coordinated to pick up a sizable collection from the NYSP. Although the guns were not part of the persons crime, they all had been taken up. ALL of them were also destroyed even though the family was in the process of recovering them (to include many of family value and sentiment). The latitude of what is NYS compliant is also very interesting with no case law to base it on or supporting findings. If you are living in the grey it is not designed for your protection.

I know there will be a lot of posts about 2d Amend being your permit and communist this and that. But IF you get in trouble, proaction and showing due diligence goes a long way and your local FFL isn’t going to destroy them or add them to their personal collection. An FFL has to put them on their register and account for them. They don’t destroy them unless law enforcement comes with an order and recovers them. Your local FFL can keep them while your innocence until prove guilty takes place.

Ok, let the lamenting begin…..
Click to expand...

Simple thing to do as well, put your handguns on another persons permit ahead of time.

Make family members aware of who can be trusted to hold all of your guns.
 
FP1201

FP1201

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,430
Reaction score
10,725
Location
Adams, NY
Grimscale said:
Isn't the other person required to live in your house and/or be related to you (by blood or marriage)?

All of my handguns are also on my wife's permit.
I only worry about any potential long guns I may, or may not, have.
Click to expand...
Jefferson County provides Forms to either Co-Register Handguns with a Family member (Husband/Wife, Father, Mother, (step)Son, (step)Daughter who also has a Licenses) or Transfer Handguns to the same, and in the case of Transfer, the transferred may co-register with their significant other.
I can transfer my Pistols to my Son who may co-register with his Wife, but I cannot co-register one with her.
If you have those Forms filled out, they can be executed at any time...
 
HEX

HEX

Please Reboot Universe
Admin
Messages
2,227
Reaction score
4,282
Location
Ulster County
GOPerfect said:
Simple thing to do as well, put your handguns on another persons permit ahead of time.

Make family members aware of who can be trusted to hold all of your guns.
Click to expand...

Big problem with this though, that I've witnessed personally. It's a very good idea to do in the event of.. say you get hurt or something, or have to leave for a trime , or whaveter else, but it can turn out to be a problem when one person in that co-registration gets into legal trouble.

I knew two fellas who co-registered all handguns with each other for that reason. One fella did a stupid one day and flashed a gun at someone he shouldn't have (road rage thing). The guy I knew better, who didn't do anything wrong, had all his handguns have to be taken specifically because they were on the other guy's permit. Eventually the guy got them back (I think) but not until after a legal battle.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
36,352
Reaction score
40,747
Location
Western NY
HEX said:
Big problem with this though, that I've witnessed personally. It's a very good idea to do in the event of.. say you get hurt or something, or have to leave for a trime , or whaveter else, but it can turn out to be a problem when one person in that co-registration gets into legal trouble.

I knew two fellas who co-registered all handguns with each other for that reason. One fella did a stupid one day and flashed a gun at someone he shouldn't have (road rage thing). The guy I knew better, who didn't do anything wrong, had all his handguns have to be taken specifically because they were on the other guy's permit. Eventually the guy got them back (I think) but not until after a legal battle.
Click to expand...
This should not be a thing. Dude who flashed the gun should have his permit revoked and end of the story. I know it’s NYS so it doesn’t work that way.
 
L

livingston

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
50,566
Reaction score
137,941
Location
livingston county
Last year the radio gun show on WYSL mentioned a case where a husband and wife had co-owned handguns. . Wife did not renew her permit. Husband had his permit in order. and legal. Anti gun judge decided all guns in the household needed to be turned in .. Has been a years long battle to get the guns back.
 
Cooolone

Cooolone

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,295
Reaction score
9,747
Location
NY, USA
The same reason a partner who lives with a DUI offender doesn't lose their property, would apply to 2A property as well... Meaning you might have to go before a Judge, but if those firearms are on your permit, you most absolutely should be able to retrieve and retain them!

Otherwise...

Bottom line is NYS has NO Jurisdiction for firearms not located within NYS!

Read that again 20x and let it sink in... Why would you turn over your firearms to a commercial enterprise within NYS arms reach? Sorry Charlie!..

But 1st thing to do is visit a friend outside the borders of NY and let that person store your firearms! When questioned about their whereabouts... Well Sir, they are not located in NY, thank you, if they were I would comply with a request to turn them over. Being as they are outside your jurisdiction, I respectfully refuse to acquiesce your request... End of story!

What's the worst thing? Contempt of court? Provide case history where a NY'er had to retrieve and surrender firearms located out of State...

If course there's some assumptions here, that you live near NY State border, making it easier to leave, and you have someone or somewhere (property) outside the State to leave your firearms...

Enjoy and have fun!
 
pshift

pshift

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,948
Reaction score
26,444
Location
Stalag 13
Cooolone said:
The same reason a partner who lives with a DUI offender doesn't lose their property, would apply to 2A property as well... Meaning you might have to go before a Judge, but if those firearms are on your permit, you most absolutely should be able to retrieve and retain them!

Otherwise...

Bottom line is NYS has NO Jurisdiction for firearms not located within NYS!

Read that again 20x and let it sink in... Why would you turn over your firearms to a commercial enterprise within NYS arms reach? Sorry Charlie!..

But 1st thing to do is visit a friend outside the borders of NY and let that person store your firearms! When questioned about their whereabouts... Well Sir, they are not located in NY, thank you, if they were I would comply with a request to turn them over. Being as they are outside your jurisdiction, I respectfully refuse to acquiesce your request... End of story!

What's the worst thing? Contempt of court? Provide case history where a NY'er had to retrieve and surrender firearms located out of State...

If course there's some assumptions here, that you live near NY State border, making it easier to leave, and you have someone or somewhere (property) outside the State to leave your firearms...

Enjoy and have fun!
Click to expand...
1759758663258.png
 
FP1201

FP1201

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,430
Reaction score
10,725
Location
Adams, NY
Cooolone said:
The same reason a partner who lives with a DUI offender doesn't lose their property, would apply to 2A property as well... Meaning you might have to go before a Judge, but if those firearms are on your permit, you most absolutely should be able to retrieve and retain them!

Otherwise...

Bottom line is NYS has NO Jurisdiction for firearms not located within NYS!

Read that again 20x and let it sink in... Why would you turn over your firearms to a commercial enterprise within NYS arms reach? Sorry Charlie!..

But 1st thing to do is visit a friend outside the borders of NY and let that person store your firearms! When questioned about their whereabouts... Well Sir, they are not located in NY, thank you, if they were I would comply with a request to turn them over. Being as they are outside your jurisdiction, I respectfully refuse to acquiesce your request... End of story!

What's the worst thing? Contempt of court? Provide case history where a NY'er had to retrieve and surrender firearms located out of State...

If course there's some assumptions here, that you live near NY State border, making it easier to leave, and you have someone or somewhere (property) outside the State to leave your firearms...

Enjoy and have fun!
Click to expand...
I figure I can rent a Truck from Enterprise, have it loaded and be out of State in under four hours.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top