Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
It's a lost cause when they are corrupt anyway. Look at the last 2 rulings. Or do you think they ruled justly?
Unrestricted to Restricted!
- Thread starter nortatoga
- Start date
nortatoga
.338 Win Mag
Which two rulings? ( Heller, McDonald?)
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
All of them. Not one of them is just according to how the 2A is written.
nortatoga
.338 Win Mag
According to you right! Not the people at the time it was written who were fine with CCW's being banned!
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
According to what's written in the actual Constitution. Not according to me. Not according to a judge. Show me where it says it's not an unlimited right in the Constitution.
That's what you don't understand or don't want to understand.
Acer-m14
20×102mm Vulcan
nope not hard at all ... the 2A shall not infringe means "do not infringe on bad guys with guns" and the FKin courts and govt assholes uphold that fully ..
hoodfu
.40 S&W
You guys can argue "shall not be infringed" all day long, but if you're caught carrying out of class, and the cop notifies the licensing bureau, you will have your license revoked and you will have to turn over your handguns. This has happened many, MANY times both in news articles and anecdotally. No I'm not going to start a google search for them, you can do that yourself. No, you won't go to jail, but some people like their handguns and don't want to lose them.
No need to start a Google search. Anybody can do that. And you'll find what anyone else will. You simply won't because you already know the answer. Hell, 2 people in this thread already did and linked us to threads in which I mentioned this exact same thing on another site.
Lots of people that "know a guy it happened to", but not once shred of evidence. In a community like this where people even post their uncouth cop infractions on forums, nobody in history has ever posted about a permit pulled for restrictions? I doubt it.
What is "out of class" anyway? Like the hallways of a school? Yeah, that I can't recommend.
Last edited:
hoodfu
.40 S&W
Sigh. I know someone who personally had their license suspended over this. Direct knowledge. Please stop giving people bad advice. It's highly irresponsible and you know it. Lobby your politician, make phone calls, send letters. This is the way we fight the system. Going on about how "carrying out of class" isn't a thing and making your little stand on an internet forum is a tempest in a teapot that won't stop anyone from facing the man when the time comes.
nortatoga
.338 Win Mag
Ok, I won't give any bad advice that comes from Internet fear mongering lies. So I won't tell people that carrying out of restrictions will get their permit revoked.
Since you sidestepped the question about a "class", which, like restrictions, didn't exist anywhere in the law, I'll assume that isn't backed by facts either.
Already addressed, in this thread.
Driving off and launching an unsecured handgun off your car roof != "got caught carrying outside of restrictions."
nortatoga
.338 Win Mag
Could you point out which # post?
Whoops, it we on one of the other of the 3 threads on this subject we currently have going on.
My bad.
New York concealed carry laws challenged in court
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
I don't believe you. Details please.
County, judge, lawyer, ect. What was the cause of this?