Multiple shot in Brooklyn, NY 36th subway station

Celt

Celt

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
9,790
Reaction score
20,331
Location
Westchester
If only good people were allowed to be armed someone could have stopped this lunatic before he caused so much carnage. This is a perfect example of why law abiding citizens should be allowed to carry in New York City and specifically on the subway. This helps prove the point that was brought up in the Supreme Court case that we are awaiting a ruling on.
 
Last edited:
RooftopKorean

RooftopKorean

6.5 Creedmoor
First Responder
Messages
2,153
Reaction score
5,067
Location
Downstate / Lake Ariel, PA
Celt said:
If only good people were allowed to be armed someone could have stopped this lunatic before he cost so much Carnage. This is a perfect example of why law abiding citizens should be allowed to carry in New York City and specifically on the subway. This helps prove the point that was brought up in the Supreme Court case that we are awaiting a ruling on.
Click to expand...

I'm all for carry conceal and I do carry when outside of the tri-state area.

In this event I feel that CCW would have made an already hectic situation FAR worse. It wasn't even a viable situation to draw with the amount of innocents and smoke.

To draw and shoot in this specific situation would be irresponsible. If the majority of people were on the deck and there was only smoke, then perhaps.
 
Mosinitis

Mosinitis

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,507
Reaction score
7,907
Location
NY state
RooftopKorean said:
Actually no, 36th St/4th Ave is predominately Puerto Rican and Dominican.

I have lived in the area my entire life and the demographic has always been the same. The Chinese section is 3-4 avenues off starting on 7 and 8 Avenues.
Click to expand...

Maybe 4th is still Hispanic, 5th you already see Chinese businesses more towards 50's streets on 6th and 7th.
 
dwa12479

dwa12479

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,143
Reaction score
14,681
Location
Dark Side of the Moon
RooftopKorean said:
I'm all for carry conceal and I do carry when outside of the tri-state area.

In this event I feel that CCW would have made an already hectic situation FAR worse. It wasn't even a viable situation to draw with the amount of innocents and smoke.

To draw and shoot in this specific situation would be irresponsible. If the majority of people were on the deck and there was only smoke, then perhaps.
Click to expand...
Yep. Makes me think of the Colorado theater shooting. Dark, smokey, chaotic... horrible situation for innocents all around.
 
L

livingston

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
50,195
Reaction score
137,102
Location
livingston county
dwa12479 said:
Yep. Makes me think of the Colorado theater shooting. Dark, smokey, chaotic... horrible situation for innocents all around.
Click to expand...
The shooting would have lasted but a short time .. Just spray and run sounds like it. Chaos all around. ... Clear shot almost impossible in a crowded car ...
 
FRANKIE

FRANKIE

.308 Win
Messages
3,472
Reaction score
4,434
Location
Lenapehoking region of NY.
tirwin1 said:
Coincidence? I think not.

apnews.com

NY lieutenant governor resigns after arrest in federal probe

New York Lt. Gov. Brian Benjamin has resigned in the wake of his arrest in a federal corruption investigation, creating a political crisis for Gov.
apnews.com apnews.com
Click to expand...
Perfect time for this shit to surface while all the quote “officials” from the government offices are standing in front of the news cameras trying to talk off yet another failed policy that happened just hours ago.
 
Celt

Celt

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
9,790
Reaction score
20,331
Location
Westchester
RooftopKorean said:
I'm all for carry conceal and I do carry when outside of the tri-state area.

In this event I feel that CCW would have made an already hectic situation FAR worse. It wasn't even a viable situation to draw with the amount of innocents and smoke.

To draw and shoot in this specific situation would be irresponsible. If the majority of people were on the deck and there was only smoke, then perhaps.
Click to expand...
Youre making assumptions that nothing could have been done to stop this guy. It might not have been feasible to use a gun defensively in this situation, the last thing any law abiding gun owner wants is collateral damage. Just because you carry a gun for self defense doesnt mean you need or have to use it in certain scenarios. But I sure as shit would rather have the option to go to gun if need be than to be left without the option.

Youre making the lefts argument for them, the old "wild west" type of reference.
 
RooftopKorean

RooftopKorean

6.5 Creedmoor
First Responder
Messages
2,153
Reaction score
5,067
Location
Downstate / Lake Ariel, PA
Celt said:
Youre making assumptions that nothing could have been done to stop this guy. It might not have been feasible to use a gun defensively in this situation, the last thing any law abiding gun owner wants is collateral damage. Just because you carry a gun for self defense doesnt mean you need or have to use it in certain scenarios. But I sure as shit would rather have the option to go to gun if need be than to be left without the option.

Youre making the lefts argument for them, the old "wild west" type of reference.
Click to expand...

How am I making the argument for the left? I'm simply stating my opinions based on footage available and my perceptions of the scene.

Would I like to be able to carry in NYC, most definitely yes. Would I have used it in this situation seeing a traincar packed with people and tons of smoke with very little visibility? Absolutely not.

This was not a run of the mill dirt bag banger who did this. This was planned and orchestrated. The traincars during rush hour are packed nut to butt and someone dropping a smoke grenade or smoke device can easily go missed. The major flag should have been the gas mask but average civilians may not pay any mind to that.

I've worked over 20 years as a NYC Paramedic in the 911 system and have seen EDPs wearing more outlandish shit than a gas mask when responding to subway assignments.
 
Last edited:
Celt

Celt

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
9,790
Reaction score
20,331
Location
Westchester
RooftopKorean said:
How am I making the argument for the left? I'm simply stating my opinions based on footage available and my perceptions of the scene.

Would I like to be able to carry in NYC, most definitely yes. Would I have used it in this situation seeing a traincar packed with people and tons of smoke with very little visibility? Absolutely not.

This was not a run of the mill dirt bag banger who did this. This was planned and orchestrated. The traincars during rush hour are packed nut to butt and someone dropping a smoke grenade or smoke device can easily go missed. The major flag should have been the gas mask but average civilians may not pay any mind to that.

I've worked over 20 years as a NYC Paramedic in the 911 system and have seen EDPs wearing more outlandish shit than a gas mask when responding to subway assignments.
Click to expand...

Without being there we cant say for sure either way. Ive worked in the subway system for over 20 years and I know it well too. Ill agree a crowded train car is not the ideal place to open fire if it can be avoided, but if someone is shooting at you and its either take a bullet or return fire what would you do?

The left loves to argue that crowded places should not allow ccw because of what you are describing, that is THEIR argument. Im not calling you a leftist, just want you to think about all aspects of this in case you arent looking at it the samw way I am.
 
GOYABEAN

GOYABEAN

.950 JDJ
Messages
34,640
Reaction score
70,572
Location
Land of Freedom PA
Don't worry NYS New Woke government officials will protect the peasant's with more more mandatory searches of carry on bags and pat down before entering all public transportation systems photo I'd and vaccine passport :nervous:
 
DoOver

DoOver

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
12,157
Reaction score
29,470
Location
Catskill Mountains Of New York
RooftopKorean said:
I'm all for carry conceal and I do carry when outside of the tri-state area.

In this event I feel that CCW would have made an already hectic situation FAR worse. It wasn't even a viable situation to draw with the amount of innocents and smoke.

To draw and shoot in this specific situation would be irresponsible. If the majority of people were on the deck and there was only smoke, then perhaps.
Click to expand...
Maybe you're right, 4 million is a lot of rounds to hump everyday.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top