New York City Changes Firearms Transport Policy Before SCOTUS Review

Marine Cpl · Apr 13, 2019

So are they going to start issuing restricted carry permits again? Because with a premise permit, you are still in violation of penal law 400 when it leaves the premises unless under certain conditions and a LEO from outside of NYC can arrest you for being in violation of the penal law.

BDinPutnam · Apr 13, 2019

"The NYPD’s focus will always be on criminals who wield illegal guns, and those who would use guns to cause violence on our streets. Reasonably accommodating the interests of licensed gun owners in transporting their firearms to a legal shooting range or second home strikes a responsible balance between individual interests and public safety.”

Reasonably accommodate my civil rights. Wasn't aware that was the standard the government was held to.

Eat a conex full of dicks, O'Neill.

misunderestimated · Apr 13, 2019

We all knew this would happen, the last thing they wanted was it to go into that court. Now is the time for us to be taking runs at the safe act.

Jmac00 · Apr 13, 2019

misunderestimated said:
We all knew this would happen, the last thing they wanted was it to go into that court. Now is the time for us to be taking runs at the safe act.

nope, not yet. Pres. Trump needs to appoint one more Justice. Justice Roberts has decided to be the "middle-of-the-road" guy. He could flip/flop on the 2A, And im not entirely comfortable with Kavanaugh's approach to the 2A. If and when Pres. Trump is re-elected and RBG decides to either step down or she passes away, THEN IT will be time to challenge the Safe Act

ArmedCorgi · Apr 13, 2019

I don't think this will affect the court hearing the case. IIRC, there was something said about this very situation and mentioned how it wouldn't negate the case.

C3D · Apr 13, 2019

Well SCOTUS may still hear the case on the basis it is a "harm capable of repetition". In any event there is no chance the Justices were going to issue a RKBA decision but instead decide on Commerce Clause grounds, so it would not have been that helpful.

livingston · Apr 13, 2019

We predicted this would happen ..

ArmedCorgi · Apr 13, 2019

Guess we'll see what happens.

Celt · Apr 13, 2019

ArmedCorgi said:
I don't think this will affect the court hearing the case. IIRC, there was something said about this very situation and mentioned how it wouldn't negate the case.

I really hope that this does not negate the court hearing the case. The case could certainly make things better. This is just the city's way to try and prevent this case from having Federal level benefits for gun owners.

SuffolkArms · Apr 13, 2019

Willjr75 said:
So are they going to start issuing restricted carry permits again? Because with a premise permit, you are still in violation of penal law 400 when it leaves the premises unless under certain conditions and a LEO from outside of NYC can arrest you for being in violation of the penal law.

Seems like they want to keep it such that you have to apply for a permit in both counties:

From Page 3 of the full PDF: https://www.supremecourt.gov/Docket...152613471_nysrpa v cny 18-180 ltr 4 12 19.pdf

Following the Osterweil decision, a New York City resident who owns a second home elsewhere in the state may apparently apply to the licensing officer in that jurisdiction for a license to possess a handgun at the second home. The Rule, however, does not currently authorize a premises licensee to transport a handgun listed on a New York City premises license to another premises where the licensee resides and is authorized to possess a handgun.

ArmedCorgi · Apr 13, 2019

SuffolkArms said:
Seems like they want to keep it such that you have to apply for a permit in both counties:

From Page 3 of the full PDF: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/18/18-280/96331/20190412152613471_nysrpa v cny 18-180 ltr 4 12 19.pdf

Just with that it seems there is still standing for a case. Having to apply for two permits to be able to do something you are supposed to be entitled to?

prambo · Apr 13, 2019

SCROTUM will not save you, me or anyone else.

They will however save the rights of "the government" to ignore natural rights.

Marine Cpl · Apr 13, 2019

The whole court system is a sham. I wouldn't put hope in it.

Burzum · Apr 13, 2019

prambo said:
SCROTUM will not save you, me or anyone else.

They will however save the rights of "the government" to ignore natural rights.

I agree, it took 10 years top hear a gun rights case and this was it, do we not have enough f-n sporter rifle bans to assess, unless there is an AR15 committing an abortion good luck getting so-called "Conservative" justices to care about it.

BDinPutnam · Apr 13, 2019

The Court should still draw this and rule on it if I'm not mistaken (I could very well be) for the reasons @ArmedCorgi and @C3D posted.

@Burzum I have to say- NYC is so egregious it is a great place to start Is it not? We have been dying the deathbed a thousand cuts for a long time. Time to start patching them and taking our cake back.

Shadow2 · Apr 13, 2019

Was there a vote? Was a law changed? Seems to me the case still has legs, all the city did was prove that the restrictions aren't based on any legal standard and are nothing but arbitrary "rules". Rules they can just as easily change back on a whim. Police where never meant to have this power. This type of shit is just as bad as ATF flip flopping every which way they want.

Airborneguy · Apr 13, 2019

Shadow2 said:
Was there a vote? Was a law changed? Seems to me the case still has legs, all the city did was prove the restriction aren't based on any legal standard and are nothing but arbitrary "rules". Rules they can just as easily be change back on a whim. Police where never meant to have this power. This type of shit is just as bad as ATF flip flopping every which way they want.

You have a very good point here. It’s a local administrative rule that can apparently be suspended by the police commissioner’s order. This is not how rights are administered and hopefully Scotus sees fit to teach them that regardless of whether O’niell (scum) is currently enforcing it or not.

Acer-m14 · Apr 13, 2019

who the Fk is O'Niell .. 1PP is a Frank Reagan ..

Marine Cpl · Apr 14, 2019

You guys see how the "Rule" is changed on a whim?

Off topic but of relevance. They used not let NYS concealed carry license holders fly out of NYC in the past and technically as per the unconstitutional penal law 265 and 400, you weren't supposed to since your license is not valid in New York City and you aren't protected through FOPA since you are making a stop when you park your car and walk with the firearm. A circuit court outside of New York's jurisdiction already ruled that FOPA does not apply to air travel. New York City allows you to anyway in contrast to the penal laws.

Now they allow it. 2 months from now they may decide not to.

No way in hell I would ever fly out of New York City when they could change rules on a whim.

Saltwater60 · Apr 14, 2019

Can I now bring my gun into nyc? I know the answer, but I agree with the case still having merit and moving forward.

MikeM · Apr 14, 2019

So goes into effect after a 30 day comment period but unsafe goes into effect in a middle of the night deal.

SuffolkArms · Apr 14, 2019

Willjr75 said:
You guys see how the "Rule" is changed on a whim?

Off topic but of relevance. They used not let NYS concealed carry license holders fly out of NYC in the past and technically as per the unconstitutional penal law 265 and 400, you weren't supposed to since your license is not valid in New York City and you aren't protected through FOPA since you are making a stop when you park your car and walk with the firearm. A circuit court outside of New York's jurisdiction already ruled that FOPA does not apply to air travel. New York City allows you to anyway in contrast to the penal laws.

Now they allow it. 2 months from now they may decide not to.

No way in hell I would ever fly out of New York City when they could change rules on a whim.

It's bullshit, at a course I took recently a man with a NYC premises permit asked if the Supreme Court case was going to make it harder for him to fly out of JFK with the handgun listed on his premises permit. They had let him fly out with it about 13 times prior..

M_F · Apr 14, 2019

SuffolkArms said:
It's bullshit, at a course I took recently a man with a NYC premises permit asked if the Supreme Court case was going to make it harder for him to fly out of JFK with the handgun listed on his premises permit. They had let him fly out with it about 13 times prior..

Did the tyrants at NYPD licensing division give the OK for him to fly out of JFK under his premises license ? It looks more like the port authority police is ignoring case law check out beach v. Kelly to laugh at some libtard judicial activist logic.

SuffolkArms · Apr 14, 2019

MFC_9 said:
Did the tyrants at NYPD licensing division give the OK for him to fly out of JFK under his premises license ? It looks more like the port authority police is ignoring case law check out beach v. Kelly to laugh at some libtard judicial activist logic.

Yep exactly, seems Port Authority wasn't complying with Beach v. Kelly in his case.

Celt · Apr 14, 2019

The NRA made a response to this.

https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2...perate-attempt-to-avoid-supreme-court-review/

spat · Apr 30, 2019

Takes years for us to get one of these cases to SCOTUS, but if Trump decides to change the color of the form the illegals have to fill out to apply for asylum there is an injunction within the hour.

A legal system can run on 2 methods, respect or fear. One of them leads to tyranny and a police state. Guess which way we are heading.

New York City Changes Firearms Transport Policy Before SCOTUS Review

.40 S&W

.577 Tyrannosaur.

.475 A&M Magnum

.223 Rem

.475 A&M Magnum

.475 A&M Magnum

.338 Win Mag

20×102mm Vulcan

.475 A&M Magnum

.450/400 Nitro Ex

.40 S&W

.475 A&M Magnum

.475 A&M Magnum

.577 Tyrannosaur.

.223 Rem

.475 A&M Magnum

6.5 Creedmoor

.338 Win Mag

20×102mm Vulcan

.577 Tyrannosaur.

20×102mm Vulcan

.44 mag

.40 S&W

.45 acp

.40 S&W

.450/400 Nitro Ex

.40 S&W

.700 Nitro Express