NYC Councilwoman Arrested For Open Carrying - Possible Sensitive Places Challenge

[Cooolone]

Have you ever fired a gun with the recoil assembly removed?

Yes indeed, it's called a revolver! Doesn't require a recoil spring either!

Come on...

Have you?

I said ONE round will fire and THAT is a functional firearm! No need for a repeat experience. But quite frankly, manually racking the slide could very well properly eject the spent round and load a new one for a repeat experience... I'm not willing to try on any of my firearms, but put a challenge out there that I'd wager if including the cost of the firearm. I'd sacrifice a Glock for the experiment, hahahaha!

Baye we should post the question to one of those online guru's hahahaha, they'd video the experiment for everyone to see. Lol



It's all good, got no dog in this fight and really couldn't care because I don't think any of us would carry a non-functional firearm INTENTIONALLY... LMAO!

 

[Truebeliever]

There is nothing in NYS law that says an inoperable firearm is not a firearm. If there's something I'm missing, I'd love to know. But I haven't been able to find it

There are specific things that have to happen federally for a firearm to be "demilled", flame cut receiver, welded firing pin channel, etc. That wasn't done here.

It’s case law. It has be operational .

 

[Truebeliever]

Yes indeed, it's called a revolver! Doesn't require a recoil spring either!

Come on...

Have you?

I said ONE round will fire and THAT is a functional firearm! No need for a repeat experience. But quite frankly, manually racking the slide could very well properly eject the spent round and load a new one for a repeat experience... I'm not willing to try on any of my firearms, but put a challenge out there that I'd wager if including the cost of the firearm. I'd sacrifice a Glock for the experiment, hahahaha!

Baye we should post the question to one of those online guru's hahahaha, they'd video the experiment for everyone to see. Lol



It's all good, got no dog in this fight and really couldn't care because I don't think any of us would carry a non-functional firearm INTENTIONALLY... LMAO!

Just remember that we are getting the info from non gun people. It might have been a different spring but misnamed as the recoil spring .

 

[dwa12479]

I get the feeling she was baiting NYC into arresting and trying her, and they didn't take the bait. I love the effort though.

 

[Saltwater60]

BTW .. remember that lady that pointed the non working pistol at a bunch of trespassers rioting on her and hubbys property ..

they put the pistol back together to make it work and charged her ..

i think the firing pin was in backwards ....

remember them ..

This is different because the guns were pointed at them. She had it holstered the entire time.

 

[Acer-m14]

This is different because the guns were pointed at them. She had it holstered the entire time.

 

[spat]

This is different because the guns were pointed at them. She had it holstered the entire time.

Also different because it was a completely different state with completely different laws.

 

[Saltwater60]

Also different because it was a completely different state with completely different laws.

That too.

 

[Acer-m14]

just saying ..

Pointing a Fist at someone should also be a charge for brandishing a weapon ..

or a hammer or baseball bat or frying pan ..

but only pointing a gun at someone to back them down will get you that charge ..

ohhh he pointed a gun at me and it scared me and i pissed my pants says the offenders as they were the Trespassers breaking the law ..