NYSRPA v. Bruen, NY 2A Case Supreme Court case and decision

[byron]

Interesting. Giardino is my sheriff, as well as having the unique distinction of also being a former County DA and county judge. I would hope having held all those positions he knows something about law. He is pretty pro 2A and had no problem handing out unrestricted permits while on the bench. Hes not as staunch or as vocal on 2a as our former Sheriff Lorey but I get the impression he is not a shitbag either.
I read his FB post and honestly didnt really get the same message. He said thats the direction its going, let it all settle out, give it a couple weeks and it will be a done deal. I am sure he is deflecting it away from being his decision. Horechul does have the ability and power to remove him.

The sheriff does not work for the governor, he is elected by the voters of the county he serves. It would take a recall election to remove him, if such is allowed in that county or state. Failing that, he is there for the rest of his term and longer if re-elected. Unless, of course, he is convicted of a crime and removed that way

1. Except in counties in the city of New York and except as authorized in section one of article nine of this constitution, registers in counties having registers shall be chosen by the electors of the respective counties once in every three years and whenever the occurring of vacancies shall require; the sheriff and the clerk of each county shall be chosen by the electors once in every three or four years as the legislature shall direct. Sheriffs shall hold no other office. They may be required by law to renew their security, from time to time; and in default of giving such new security, their offices shall be deemed vacant. The governor may remove any elective sheriff, county clerk, district attorney or register within the term for which he or she shall have been elected; but before so doing the governor shall give to such officer a copy of the charges against him or her and an opportunity of being heard in his or her defense. In each county a district attorney shall be chosen by the electors once in every three or four years as the legislature shall direct. The clerk of each county in the city of New York shall be appointed, and be subject to removal, by the appellate division of the supreme court in the judicial department in which the county is located. In addition to his or her powers and duties as clerk of the supreme court, he or she shall have power to select, draw, summon and empanel grand and petit jurors in the manner and under the conditions now or hereafter prescribed by law, and shall have such other powers and duties as shall be prescribed by the city from time to time by local law.

 

[Rap]

It's actually constriction of freedom for upstate concealed carriers, who would wind up with additional gun free zones (if what he speculates on comes to pass regarding "sensitive areas").

 

[Acer-m14]

has anyone called there local sheriff and pistol permit office and asked how much is a Voting license and how much training do you need ? LMAO

 

[Acer-m14]

i seen someone mention about someone from out of state file for a NY PP .. they should fking do it .. another law suit .. cuz you need to own property in NY currenty to do that .. and now .. that is not in the history and text of the 2A .. and NY doesn't acknowledge other states permits ..

 

[gun_slinger_boy]

 

[nortatoga]

Glad to see these videos from Four Boxes Dinner are catching on here, I've been watching them for awhile now!! This lawyer is really sharp..

 

[gun_slinger_boy]

Glad to see these videos from Four Boxes Dinner are catching on here, I've been watching them for awhile now!! This lawyer is really sharp..

I like the nice clean reporting. Just the facts.

 

[pshift]

Big news for Rockland county…. This will likely be posted by the Rockland Pistol Clerk very soon.

The Sportman/Residence restrictions will no longer apply.

Hopefully Westchester County will follow. We can only hope since I was going to file my amendment this week. I just might wait a wek or two until the dust settles. There is no sense in wasting gas or a stamp to exercise my right.

 

[Phazer]

Hopefully Westchester County will follow. We can only hope since I was going to file my amendment this week. I just might wait a wek or two until the dust settles. There is no sense in wasting gas or a stamp to exercise my right.

Don't hold your breath for Westchester. You'll suffocate.

Remember, we have a communist county executive.

 

[NYCGuy]

I took my first boating course the other day on a 22 ft center cosole. I could not believe they allow people to purchase boats a drive them amongst other capable boaters, without any type of training/testing required. I was shocked at how hard it was to even get the boat into a slip or dock it. It takes great finesse!

Reminded me of the first time I shot a pistol, couldn’t get shots on target at 7 yards.

As far as I am concerned the only two part test that should be used is that of NICS and can you put shots on target at 7 yards? If you can’t put shots on target you can’t have a gun, forget all the good moral character garbage, that’s the only test they should be concerned with.

 

[Edwardteach72]

As far as I am concerned the only two part test that should be used is that of NICS and can you put shots on target at 7 yards? If you can’t put shots on target you can’t have a gun, forget all the good moral character garbage, that’s the only test they should be concerned with.

Fuck both of those

 

[maverick52]

Just heard Hochul on 880 news. Bragging about how she will keep NY safe by making everywhere a sensitive area. Said she will not allow NY to become the wild Wild West. You know this is all for her November campaign. I really hope whatever laws get passed this week are slapped down real hard and real soon.

 

[Edwardteach72]

Just heard Hochul on 880 news. Bragging about how she will keep NY safe by making everywhere a sensitive area. Said she will not allow NY to become the wild Wild West. You know this is all for her November campaign. I really hope whatever laws get passed this week are slapped down real hard and real soon.

Funny part... the "Wild Wild West" was anti 2A and pro gun restrictions inside towns...

She legit would want to make it the Wild Wild West..

 

[Phazer]

Just heard Hochul on 880 news. Bragging about how she will keep NY safe by making everywhere a sensitive area. Said she will not allow NY to become the wild Wild West. You know this is all for her November campaign. I really hope whatever laws get passed this week are slapped down real hard and real soon.

The cities already are! Due to criminals.

Time to get out of the way and let law-abiding citizens defend themselves.

 

[maverick52]

The cities already are! Due to criminals.

Time to get out of the way and let law-abiding citizens defend themselves.

I wonder if they actually believe what they say or they know they are full of it.

 

[LibertyWins]

I wonder if they actually believe what they say or they know they are full of it.

Exactly. Every time she and the left repeatedly says "keep NY safe" when all they're doing is making it harder for us to protect ourselves, I'm cringing to myself about how backwards their thought process is. They must know, on some level, that what they're saying makes no sense!

Keeping us safe would mean allowing us law abiding citizens to carry just about anywhere we go so we can defend ourselves and those around us from criminals who don't care about the law. But this is the left we're talking about. None of their shenanigan's makes any sense these days. They're all insane liberal extremist's, who seem to be obsessed with depopulation through multiple means -- whether they know it or not.

 

[gun_slinger_boy]

I wonder if they actually believe what they say or they know they are full of it.

They must know, on some level, that what they're saying makes no sense!

An overwhelming majority of politicians know the truth and that what they are spouting is bullshit. Statistics are easy to read. With few exceptions like those that think magazines are one time use or those that think an island can sink they know what they are saying are lies. Their constituents are the ones that believe what the politicians say. They are actually dumb. If not being of actual inferior intelligence then too dumb to take 2 minutes to research information.

 

[NY Chamorro]

think an island can sink they know what they are saying are lies

or on drugs...I cant believe that asshat was saying that, about my island..

 

[Phazer]

An overwhelming majority of politicians know the truth and that what they are spouting is bullshit. Statistics are easy to read. With few exceptions like those that think magazines are one time use or those that think an island can sink they know what they are saying are lies.

Bingo!

I recently had a Leftist tell me how bad "high capacity" magazines are. I said, "Oh...really?" They explained that having to change magazines makes the shooter vulnerable while reloading. I then did a little demonstration: With them 20 feet away, I pointed my finger at them and went "Bang, bang, bang." I told them that when they hear "Click," I'm empty and that is their chance to get to me and stop my "rampage." When I said, "Click," I went through the motion of dropping an empty mag, pulling a pretend magazine from my pocket, seated the magazine, racked my NY-approved-finger-gun, and then said "Bang" again after about 2 seconds (I know...a really long reload time). The Leftist had just barely processed the "click" when I was already reloaded and "shooting" again. An intellectually honest person would have learned that magazine capacity is fairly irrelevant, except when fractions of a second count and one needs to defend themselves against multiple assailants. But, this Leftist will probably just come to the conclusion that all gunz iz bad and should be banned.

 

[Uninformed and Compliant]

As far as I am concerned the only two part test that should be used is that of NICS and can you put shots on target at 7 yards? If you can’t put shots on target you can’t have a gun, forget all the good moral character garbage, that’s the only test they should be concerned with.

Because a woman who can only hit a target when it's laying on top of her should have a state compelled obligation to be chain raped until she bleeds to death.

You are sick, and defective.

 

[NY Chamorro]

Bingo!

I recently had a Leftist tell me how bad "high capacity" magazines are. I said, "Oh...really?" They explained that having to change magazines makes the shooter vulnerable while reloading. I then did a little demonstration: With them 20 feet away, I pointed my finger at them and went "Bang, bang, bang." I told them that when they hear "Click," I'm empty and that is their chance to get to me and stop my "rampage." When I said, "Click," I went through the motion of dropping an empty mag, pulling a pretend magazine from my pocket, seated the magazine, racked my NY-approved-finger-gun, and then said "Bang" again after about 2 seconds (I know...a really long reload time). The Leftist had just barely processed the "click" when I was already reloaded and "shooting" again. An intellectually honest person would have learned that magazine capacity is fairly irrelevant, except when fractions of a second count and one needs to defend themselves against multiple assailants. But, this Leftist will probably just come to the conclusion that all gunz iz bad and should be banneIts

 

[NY Chamorro]

Good thing you didn't pull out your assult finger, he probably would have been slipping on his liberal tears.

 

[dwa12479]

I took my first boating course the other day on a 22 ft center cosole. I could not believe they allow people to purchase boats a drive them amongst other capable boaters, without any type of training/testing required. I was shocked at how hard it was to even get the boat into a slip or dock it. It takes great finesse!

Reminded me of the first time I shot a pistol, couldn’t get shots on target at 7 yards.

As far as I am concerned the only two part test that should be used is that of NICS and can you put shots on target at 7 yards? If you can’t put shots on target you can’t have a gun, forget all the good moral character garbage, that’s the only test they should be concerned with.

SHALL. NOT. BE. INFRINGED.

 

[nortatoga]

think an island can sink they know what they are saying are lies

or on drugs...I cant believe that asshat was saying that, about my island..

No it was worse he said the island could capsize LOL!!

 

[Phazer]

No it was worse he said the island could capsize LOL!!

 

[gun_slinger_boy]

Bingo!

I recently had a Leftist tell me how bad "high capacity" magazines are. I said, "Oh...really?" They explained that having to change magazines makes the shooter vulnerable while reloading. I then did a little demonstration: With them 20 feet away, I pointed my finger at them and went "Bang, bang, bang." I told them that when they hear "Click," I'm empty and that is their chance to get to me and stop my "rampage." When I said, "Click," I went through the motion of dropping an empty mag, pulling a pretend magazine from my pocket, seated the magazine, racked my NY-approved-finger-gun, and then said "Bang" again after about 2 seconds (I know...a really long reload time). The Leftist had just barely processed the "click" when I was already reloaded and "shooting" again. An intellectually honest person would have learned that magazine capacity is fairly irrelevant, except when fractions of a second count and one needs to defend themselves against multiple assailants. But, this Leftist will probably just come to the conclusion that all gunz iz bad and should be banned.

Just show them this next time. It takes "high" capacity, semi automatic and closing distance off the table as an argument.

 

[Phazer]

Just show them this next time. It takes "high" capacity, semi automatic and closing distance off the table as an argument.

Jerry Miculek with a revolver: 8 rounds in 1 second. That's 480 rounds per minute. Quick....impound his trigger finger.

 

[Newguyhere]

According to the CDC data for 2020, nearly 5x more people died from overdose than from firearms, yet we have needle exchange programs and people shooting up in public parks in NYC and the police ignore it. Add to that, bail reform and criminals running wild on the streets.

There must be something in the NYC water supply that makes people vote for these people.

 

[Tisto]

According to the CDC data for 2020, nearly 5x more people died from overdose than from firearms, yet we have needle exchange programs and people shooting up in public parks in NYC and the police ignore it. Add to that, bail reform and criminals running wild on the streets.

There must be something in the NYC water supply that makes people vote for these people.

If there is something in the water, you can damn well bet that the people being voted for are the ones that put it there in the first place.

 

[Grimscale]

I took my first boating course the other day on a 22 ft center cosole. I could not believe they allow people to purchase boats a drive them amongst other capable boaters, without any type of training/testing required. I was shocked at how hard it was to even get the boat into a slip or dock it. It takes great finesse!

Reminded me of the first time I shot a pistol, couldn’t get shots on target at 7 yards.

As far as I am concerned the only two part test that should be used is that of NICS and can you put shots on target at 7 yards? If you can’t put shots on target you can’t have a gun, forget all the good moral character garbage, that’s the only test they should be concerned with.

I am sorry to hear you are so incompetent with regards to not only boating, but shooting as well.
The first time I put a boat in the water it was quite easy. Pulling away from the dock I didn't even scrape the hull, and moving among other boaters was no different than driving down the road.
You CAN drive down the road, right?
Bringing the boat back into the dock and onto the trailer was similarly easy.

With regard to shooting: the first time I shot a pistol I had no difficulty getting 10 rounds in an 8x10 target at 50 feet. This was a full size 9mm, and I had never shot a pistol before. It didn't take long before I was hitting bullseyes.

While I believe it is in someone's best interests to practice and become proficient with their firearm that ABSOLUTELY is not a requirement for owning and carrying. Sometimes even just showing a gun can save a life.

in addition, you CANNOT legally touch a pistol in NY unless you have a permit. And if you can't practice, how do you get the permit to be able to practice to get good enough to get the permit?